Columbus has plenty of places to satisfy a sweet tooth. From old-fashioned chocolate shops and Ohio buckeyes to imported candy, handmade fudge, and unusual sodas, the city offers something for nearly every candy lover.
Whether you are shopping for a gift, planning a family outing, or searching for a new treat, these are some of the best candy stores in Columbus, Ohio.
1. Rocket Fizz Soda Pop & Candy Shop
Address: 944 N. High St., Columbus, OH 43201
Rocket Fizz Soda Pop & Candy Shop is a fun stop for shoppers who enjoy nostalgic sweets, unusual sodas, and novelty products. Located in the Short North, the store carries a large assortment of retro candy, saltwater taffy, international treats, chocolate, and bottled drinks in hard-to-find flavors.
The shelves are packed with products from different decades, making Rocket Fizz a good place to rediscover childhood favorites. The store also carries gag gifts and novelty items, so visitors can browse for much more than candy.
Best for: Retro candy, unusual soda flavors, imported sweets, and novelty gifts.
2. The Candy Spot
Address: 1611 N. High St., Columbus, OH 43201
The Candy Spot offers a colorful selection of popular American candy, international sweets, gummies, chocolates, sour treats, and freeze-dried candy. Many of its products have gained attention through social media, making it a popular stop for shoppers searching for newer candy trends.
Customers may find treats imported from Asia, Europe, Mexico, and other regions alongside familiar brands. The store also has Columbus-area locations at Polaris Fashion Place and Tanger Outlets Columbus.
Best for: Trending candy, freeze-dried treats, international sweets, and sour candy.
3. Buckeye Candy Company
Address: 104 Granville St., Gahanna, OH 43230
Buckeye Candy Company is located in nearby Gahanna and offers a broad assortment of candy for adults and children. The shop carries classic favorites, gummies, chocolate, novelty candy, and newer products that are difficult to find in standard grocery stores.
Its wide selection makes it a convenient destination for family candy shopping, birthday treats, gift baskets, and special occasions. Customers can browse a mix of familiar brands and less common sweets in a friendly neighborhood setting.
Best for: Family candy shopping, gift-worthy treats, gummies, and classic candy.
4. Anthony-Thomas Factory Shoppe
Address: 1777 Arlingate Lane, Columbus, OH 43228
Anthony-Thomas is one of the best-known candy companies in Columbus. The Ohio chocolatier has produced chocolates since 1952 and remains a popular destination for visitors searching for locally made candy.
The Factory Shoppe sells traditional Ohio buckeyes, boxed chocolates, pecan dainties, chocolate bars, seasonal candy, and other confections. Scheduled factory tours may also be available, giving visitors a chance to learn how the company produces its chocolates.
Anthony-Thomas is an especially good choice for anyone who wants to bring home a candy gift connected to Columbus and Ohio.
Best for: Ohio buckeyes, boxed chocolates, seasonal candy, and factory tours.
5. Schmidt’s Fudge Haus
Address: 220 E. Kossuth St., Columbus, OH 43206
Located in German Village, Schmidt’s Fudge Haus specializes in handmade fudge and traditional chocolate treats. Visitors can choose from several fudge flavors along with hand-dipped buckeyes, turtles, caramel, chocolate-covered pretzels, and the shop’s signature Schmurtles.
The store’s location also makes it easy to combine a candy stop with a visit to Schmidt’s Sausage Haus or a walk through the historic German Village neighborhood.
Schmidt’s Fudge Haus is a strong choice for visitors who prefer rich, old-fashioned candy made in small batches.
Best for: Handmade fudge, chocolate-covered treats, buckeyes, and German Village sightseeing.
6. Pure Imagination Chocolatier
Address: 1205 Grandview Ave., Grandview Heights, OH 43212
Pure Imagination Chocolatier creates handmade chocolates and small-batch confections in Grandview Heights. Its selection may include truffles, chocolate bars, caramels, seasonal products, and carefully prepared gift boxes.
The shop is a good option for birthdays, holidays, anniversaries, and other occasions that call for a more refined chocolate gift. Product selections may change during the year, giving returning customers new flavors and seasonal items to try.
Best for: Artisan chocolate, handmade truffles, caramels, and upscale gifts.
7. Krema Nut Company
Address: 1000 Goodale Blvd., Columbus, OH 43212
Krema Nut Company has served Columbus customers since 1898. The store is widely known for freshly roasted nuts, natural nut butters, chocolate-covered nuts, hand-rolled buckeyes, and Buckeye Crunch.
The retail shop also has a carryout counter where customers can order peanut butter sandwiches, milkshakes, and other specialties. Anyone who enjoys the combination of peanut butter and chocolate will find plenty of tempting options here.
Krema offers a different experience from a traditional candy store because it combines sweets with roasted nuts and freshly prepared nut butter products.
Best for: Peanut butter candy, chocolate-covered nuts, buckeyes, and milkshakes.
8. Eagle Family Candy Company
Address: 4590 N. High St., Columbus, OH 43214
Eagle Family Candy Company is an old-fashioned chocolate shop located in Clintonville. The family-owned business is known for traditional handmade candy, including caramels, turtles, buckeyes, and solid chocolate figures.
The shop provides a personal alternative to larger candy retailers. Its traditional production methods and family history have made it a distinctive part of the Columbus candy scene.
Eagle Family Candy Company is worth visiting for shoppers who appreciate classic recipes and locally made chocolate.
Best for: Handmade chocolates, caramels, turtles, and traditional candy.
9. Winans Coffee + Chocolate
Address: 1125 Yard St., Suite 240, Columbus, OH 43212
Winans Coffee + Chocolate combines a coffee shop with a full chocolate counter. Customers can pair a freshly prepared drink with handmade chocolates, buckeyes, caramels, cordials, chocolate assortments, and gift boxes.
The store is a convenient choice for anyone who wants to sit down with a coffee while shopping for sweets. Winans also has additional Columbus-area locations, including shops in the Short North and German Village.
Best for: Coffee, handmade chocolate, gift boxes, buckeyes, and caramels.
Choosing the Best Columbus Candy Store
The right shop depends on the type of treat you want.
Rocket Fizz is a strong choice for retro candy and unusual soda. The Candy Spot is ideal for trending and international sweets, while Anthony-Thomas offers some of the best-known Columbus-made chocolates and buckeyes.
For handmade fudge, visit Schmidt’s Fudge Haus. Pure Imagination Chocolatier works well for artisan gifts, and Krema Nut Company is a must-visit for peanut butter and chocolate fans. Eagle Family Candy Company offers a traditional neighborhood candy-shop experience, while Winans combines chocolates with coffee.
With so many candy stores across Columbus and the surrounding communities, finding a new favorite treat should be easy.
